I received my nook yesterday! To review it, I've considered some aspects of the device and have given them a letter grade from A+ to F.
So here goes:
- Packaging - C+ - Packaging was confusing. Trying to find the right way to pull off the plastic, even with the guide that comes with it, was a big hassle. Other than that, once that is over, everything is a lot better.
- Functionality - A+ - The nook has PDF support, EPUB support, Fictionwise support, plays MP3s in a dedicated player on the bottom color screen, has OverDrive library support for renting books through Adobe Digital Editions, AT&T 3G and WiFi, microSD support, and LendMe. Lots of features for an eReader device.
- Realistically flawless operation (no bugs) - B - most of the time the nook acts fine as it is supposed to, however there are occasional "can not connect" errors as well as minor interface glitches, such as Android-style "Force Quit" windows. One time the bottom screen somehow appeared on the top for a small while. Also, device error messages should be more clear as to their cause. One of the errors was caused by an account default credit card payment setting that wasn't set. Lagginess is not really a problem. It is either really exaggerated or a software update happened that really fixed it. As for the "Formatting" message on the screen when opening the book, it's really not a problem; it goes away pretty quick and actually makes the eBook look a lot better.
- Battery life - A- - I can't really say a lot about this as I've only had it for a short while. But I can say that it depends on how much you use it and on your nook's settings.
I seriously think that Barnes and Noble has a lot of potential with this eBook device. Updates done to it through the 3G or WiFi connection should fix a lot of its bugs and help it make the Kindle run and hide. If Barnes and Noble keeps on supporting it with updates and other support, the nook can potentially become the best eReader there is.

Read the rest of this post »